'I Know What You Did Last Summer' Cast -- 'Memba Them?!

Everett Collection

1 / 16

Sarah Michelle Gellar is iconic in her role as Croaker Queen herself, Helen Shivers. She has big dreams for after high school, but her aspirations are cut short after an epic chase scene with the killer.

Everett Collection

2 / 16

Sarah Michelle Gellar -- now 44-years-old -- shared an icy photo recently that is worthy of a crown!

3 / 16

Muse Watson isn't off the hook just yet for his portrayal of the revenge-seeking killer, Ben Willis. His mysterious identity is kept under wraps until he is revealed to be the same hit-and-run victim dumped in the ocean a year earlier.

Everett Collection

4 / 16

Muse Watson -- now 73-years-old -- posted a photo of himself recently looking fishy.

5 / 16

Freddie Prinze Jr. plays the lead role of Ray Bronson, Julie's first love and a fisherman in the town. He was driving the car that killer night of July 4th, but he escaped Ben Willis' revenge ... for now.

Everett Collection

6 / 16

Freddie Prinze Jr. -- now 45-years-old -- was seen recently working on his fighting tactics!

7 / 16

Jennifer Love Hewitt is best known as scream queen Julie James. After returning from college, she is haunted by the actions of her and her friends that dreadful night of July 4th.

Everett Collection

8 / 16

Jennifer Love Hewitt -- now 42-years-old -- was seen recently looking screamin'.

Getty

9 / 16

Ryan Phillippe is best known for his role as Barry Cox, the tough guy of the group. He is the first of the friends to meet his demise, getting stabbed during the Croaker Queen pageant while his girlfriend, Helen, watches.

Everett Collection

10 / 16

Ryan Phillippe -- now 47-years-old -- was seen last week at a spooky showing of the movie at the Hollywood Cemetery!

Getty

11 / 16

Bridgette Wilson is best known as Elsa Shivers -- the older sister of golden child, Helen. She longs to make her sister's life difficult, that is until ... she gets her neck slashed in her own department store.

Everett Collection

12 / 16

Bridgette Wilson -- now 48-years-old -- was spotted recently alive and well. She's still off the hook!

Getty

13 / 16

Johnny Galecki played the role of Max Neurick, the nerdy outcast pining after the affection of Julie. His tragic death occurred with a hook through his chin.