TMZ Live: Beyonce Goes Live ... but Way Too Far to Prove Her Point

TMZ Live Beyonce Goes Live ... But Way Too Far!!

0-f1x6zm88

Beyonce sticks it to the haters -- belting out the National Anthem ... LIVE! No doubt she can sing, but did the move seem a little desperate? The newsroom got loud and heated over that question.

Plus, San Francisco 49er Chris Culliver made horribly homophobic comments -- but his apology might have made it worse! So, will the team let him play in the Super Bowl? We'll explain why we think he will play, and why that's fine.

And, supermodel Bar Refaeli says she wants to make a nerd's night by talking to him at a bar -- does that make her an angel or a bitch??

TMZ Live Justin Bieber Alleged Battery Mike Tyson Sounds Off :: tmzlive-download-podcast-graphic

TMZ Live Justin Bieber Alleged Battery Mike Tyson Sounds Off :: tmzlive-play-by-play-3

(0:00) San Francisco 49ers player Chris Culliver's apology is just as idiotic as his homophobic rant -- the question ... should he be able to play in the Super Bowl?
(10:00) Beyonce proves everyone wrong by singing the National Anthem at a Super Bowl press conference -- was it badass ... or a desperate move?
(18:00) Bar Refaeli says she wants to talk to more dorky dudes at bars in order to make their day ... and she's totally right.
(24:00) Lindsay Lohan owes Shawn Holley a boat load of money -- yet eats at the most expensive restaurants and stays in the most expensive hotels in L.A..
(29:00) Ronaiah Tuiasosopo thinks being gay is something you can "recover" from. So, yeah.
(32:00) Dustin Hoffman blames TMZ for the cancellation of "Luck" -- but he couldn't be more wrong.
(35:00) Ron Jeremy -- don't be afraid to admit you know he's a porn star, Emmy Rossum.
(38:00) The floor is yours!
(43:00) It's time again for ... Tim's worst pitches of the week!